Philosophical Ramblings

I want to start with this:  There’s going to be a bit of a “Jews are the chosen people and have been persecuted for thousands of years” theme here, so let’s get a couple things clear first, to avoid hurt feelings.  To non-Jewish readers, please remember that I hold you all in as high regard as I ever did and appreciate you being part of my life.  To Jewish readers, please remember the old “two Jews, three opinions” adage, and don’t feel like I’m pressuring any of you to believe or observe the way that I do.

So, let’s go chronologically.

My father has a friend who is a Seventh-day Adventist minister, and he referred this friend to me when a question about Judaism came up in their correspondence.  (Apparently, being a seminary girl makes one a “higher authority” when it comes to questions about Jewish practice….)  This minister and I have, since then, been involved in (totally friendly on both sides) email debating since then.  It’s good for me, actually, as I’m having to look up sources and figure out exactly what is right when it comes to such basic things as G-d being one, Shabbos being an eternal weekly gift for the Jews, and there being 613 commandments in the Torah.  I’m working on my latest response to him now.  I look forward to further debate with this person, and hope he someday gets around to reading this entry!

Then I had an incredibly weird dream last night.  In the dream, I had somehow been forced to leave Israel against my will.  It started with me on the plane, except the plane looked more like a bus, with seats facing each other and such.  My dad, stepmother, and sister picked me up and brought me to my new apartment, which I’d never seen before.  At this point, I literally didn’t even know what state I was in.  So, I met my roommates, one of them a girl who told me she was also an Orthodox Jew, and the other, my cousin (we don’t do names here, but I will say for those in the know that this particular cousin is the oldest son of my father’s sister).  Now, since this cousin is a male and this other girl is an Orthodox Jew, there is a bit of a problem with the three of us living together.  But apparently we were at least going to have a kosher kitchen, though this cousin doesn’t, as far as I know, keep kosher in real life.  So I was all sad and culture-shocked about the lack of religious Jewish life in the area, but then I found out that there was a Chabad house next door and a kosher deli down the street.  And I found out that I was in Richmond, Virginia, which…okay, fine, I don’t actually know much about the Jewish life there.  So my sister and I go to this kosher deli and I start crying to her about how I miss Israel and I’d been forced to leave Israel so abruptly (“I mean, we don’t even have internet in our apartment yet!  And I had Shabbos plans already!”).  And then I woke up.  I’m not really sure what any of that means…any thoughts??

And today, we learned from the text “Michtav Me’Eliyahu”, a classic work of Jewish ethics.  It referenced the story in the Talmud about the persecution of the Jews by the Romans.  This story records a secular Jew coming to Rabbi Akiva and saying, “I don’t understand.  Why do you study Torah when it has been outlawed?  You will be killed if they find out you are still studying and teaching!”  Rabbi Akiva responded along the lines of “Yes, but a Jew without Torah is a fish out of water.  I might die from Torah study, but I’d die [spiritually] without it even faster.”  Time passed and both Akiva and this secular guy got arrested–the latter simply for being Jewish.  He came to Akiva and said, “Rabbi, I envy you–you got arrested for doing something you love and which G-d loves that you do, but I got arrested for nothing!”  The rabbi who was teaching this class pointed out that this was but a precursor to what would happen in twentieth-century Germany–Jews being killed merely for being Jews and not because of the way they practice.

And that, actually, is a big part of why I got into religious Judaism.  If I’m going to be hated anyway for being descended from Jews (and let’s face it, there’s still an awful lot of anti-Semitism out there), then why not learn what being Jewish is all about?  Why not learn to practice the faith of my fathers the way it’s been practiced since the time of the Torah?  Truthfully, I don’t understand how any Jew would not want the immense rewards of a Jewish life.  (I admit to being in the minority here, even among the Orthodox.  Many people who grew up with this religion look at people like myself and ask why the heck we chose the path they were born into.)

Thus end my philosophical ramblings.  I’m off to dinner. 🙂

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Philosophical Ramblings

  1. David Schwartz says:

    Hmm… Well, your dream could be concerns about what will happen when you come back to the States. It’s said that dreams are your brain processing things it experiences during the day that we might not be consciously aware of, so perhaps you encountered somebody going back to the States or coming from the States or you had a thought about your life in the States, and your brain took that and ran with it.

    Also, growing up in the Buckle of the Bible Belt (Chattanooga, TN) I have much experience with discussions as you described your correspondence to be, so if you ever want a thought about a particular point that’s come up, feel free to let me know.

    And by the way, nobody lives Judaism “the way it’s been practiced since the time of the Torah.” The closest you could do would be to become a Karaite. Judaism has evolved since Abraham served meat and cheese together to the angels until this day; it’s merely a matter of when you want to stop the clock on the evolution that determines your lifestyle.

    • Ah, thanks David for pointing out that I worded my Torah thoughts a bit too vaguely in an effort to be user-friendly.

      When it comes to practicing the same way they did since they got the Torah, what I was thinking of was the beginning of Pirkei Avos: “Moshe kibel Torah miSinai” and then it got passed down to Yehoshua and the elders and etc. Actually, one of my rabbis gave us a “timeline” with teachers from Moshe to US. As in, Talmudic rabbis to medieval rabbis (yes, he had specific names) to modern rabbis to rabbis of the last generations to this rabbi, who really had been taught by the greatest rabbis of the last generation…and from this rabbi to us. And that’s how Judaism’s been practiced since then…with decisions being made by the Gedolei Hador.

  2. BKop says:

    Another beautiful post!
    Your remarks are most insightful.
    In fact, they could serve as an explanation for my Whale of Grief
    collection, my poems about being Jewish.
    As ever, I respect your decision and your candor,
    even more your good heart, a beacon to us all.
    As for your dream, I think that it may have been in anticipation of what
    you were going to study about Rabbi Akiva. It also suggest that you are,
    for better or worse, ‘married’ to all Jews, even those of us who do not practice
    anywhere close to the 613 that you try to. All of us are still related.
    For me, that’s a wonderful thought to consider.
    As ever, I send this
    with all my love


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s